How to keep a trading journal that improves your trading
What to write down for every trade, how to review it, and the numbers that show whether you have an edge.
Updated 20 November 2026 ยท by XJournaling
A trading journal is a record of every trade you take: what you traded, where you entered, where your stop and target were, the result, a picture of the chart, and why you took it. That last part matters most. Prices tell you what happened; your notes tell you why it happened, and the why is the only part you can change.
This guide explains what to write down, how to review it, and the numbers that show whether you actually have an edge.
Why keep a trading journal?
Without a record, memory does the reviewing, and memory is biased. You remember the big winner and forget the five small rule breaks that came before it. A journal replaces that with evidence:
- It shows which setups make money. When every trade is tagged with its setup, you can see which ones pay and which ones only feel good.
- It shows which mistakes cost money. Tag mistakes (moved stop, chased entry, traded the news, revenge trade) and add up what each one cost.
- It keeps you inside your rules. On a funded or challenge account, one bad day can break the daily loss limit. Seeing the limit next to today's result changes how you trade the rest of the day.
- It turns feelings into numbers. "I'm trading badly" becomes "my win rate on London breakouts dropped this month while my New York reversals held up".
What to record for every trade
| Field | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Date, time and session | Shows when you trade best (for example London vs New York). |
| Instrument and direction | Long or short, and on what (EURUSD, NQ, gold...). |
| Entry, stop loss, take profit | Needed to calculate risk and the R-multiple. |
| Size (lots or contracts) | Checks you respected your risk per trade and contract limits. |
| Result in money and in R | Money for the account, R to compare trades fairly. |
| Setup | The pattern or model you traded, so results can be grouped. |
| Chart screenshot | Before and after. Your future self needs to see what you saw. |
| Why you took it / why it won or lost | One or two honest sentences. |
| Mistakes | Tags such as "moved stop" or "no plan", so you can count them. |
| Account | Which funded or personal account the trade was on. |
Add a short daily note too: your plan before the session, how you felt, and one lesson for tomorrow.
How to review your journal
Daily (5 minutes)
Check each trade against your plan. Did you follow it? Tag any mistake while it is fresh, and write one lesson.
Weekly (20 minutes)
Look at the week's P&L by day, by setup and by session. Find the one thing that cost you the most and pick a single rule to fix it next week.
Monthly
Look at the bigger numbers: win rate, average R, expectancy and profit factor, and how far you are from each account's profit target and loss limits.
The numbers that matter
- Win rate: winning trades divided by all trades.
- R-multiple: the result of a trade measured in units of the risk you took. A trade that risked $100 and made $250 is +2.5R.
- Expectancy: what you make on average per trade, in R or in money. Positive expectancy means an edge.
- Profit factor: total money won divided by total money lost. Above 1 means the strategy made money.
- Streaks and drawdown: how long losing runs last and how deep they go, which tells you how much room your account rules really give you.
The formulas, with worked examples, are in our guide R-multiple, expectancy and profit factor explained.
Spreadsheet or trading journal app?
A spreadsheet works and costs nothing, but it needs discipline: typing every field by hand, pasting screenshots, writing formulas and keeping them correct. A journal app does the math for you, keeps the chart with the trade, and shows your account rules live. Use whichever you will actually keep up every day; the best journal is the one you fill in.
Questions traders ask
What is a trading journal?
A trading journal is a record of every trade you take: the entry, stop, target, result, a screenshot of the chart and why you took it. Reviewing it shows which setups make money and which mistakes cost you.
What should I write in a trading journal?
For each trade: date and session, instrument, direction, entry, stop loss, take profit, size, result in money and in R, the setup, a chart screenshot, why you took it, and any mistakes. Add a short daily note with your plan and one lesson.
How often should I review my trading journal?
Briefly after every session, in more depth once a week, and once a month for the bigger statistics like expectancy and profit factor.
Keep this journal without spreadsheets. XJournaling tracks every funded account's rules live, logs each trade with its chart, and calculates your win rate, expectancy, profit factor and R-multiple for you.
See XJournaling